Tony's Pizzalicious | Our Story
A Cayce landmark since 1967
Tony’s Pizzalicious and Spaghetti House has been feeding Cayce on Knox Abbott Drive since 1967. The building went up when some nearby roads were still unpaved, and for years it was run by a local family. In 2010, Steve took over, renovated the restaurant from top to bottom, and installed new ovens—preserving a neighborhood landmark while giving it a fresh start. Nearly six decades later, the same community spirit lives on.
The original Tony's
Tony opened on Knox Abbott Drive in 1967, and the place never really changed — and that’s exactly the point. Generations of guests have made memories here, from first dates in the booths to bringing their own grandchildren years later. Regulars return for decades, while new neighbors continue to discover the same welcoming, family-like atmosphere. A neighborhood restaurant that earned its stripes one loyal guest at a time.
Two traditions, one table
The menu brings old-style Northern Italian comfort food to the Deep South, with everything made from scratch. Hand-tossed dough, homemade sauce, and Tony’s special four-cheese blend set the foundation, while the famous spaghetti with real meat sauce remains a longtime favorite. Italian classics share the menu with Greek favourites like the Greek Gyro Salad and Greek Gyro Pizza, making the combination feel completely natural.
A place to gather
Red booths for dine-in, carryout on a weeknight, or the back room for a birthday — Tony's has always made room for everyone.
A local landmark
OnlyInYourState called Tony's a "must-try" and "a local landmark" — and honestly, Cayce already knew that. When a restaurant runs for nearly sixty years on the same street, the community has spoken.